Tuesday, January 31, 2017

What Nubian Remains Show Us

Hi everyone!

My Big Fat Greek Wedding 2 funny movie comedy family

It's seemed that this week has gone by so quickly! I thought the meme was appropriate since I got back from a large Greek gathering. For those who wanted to know what happened at FDF the Greek Folk Dance Competition in San Diego, my group, Voanerges, won a Founder's Achievement Award which was awesome. What is really cool about FDF though is that dance groups come from all over the country from Arizona, California, Oregon, and even Hawaii!

Now, as to my research at the BONE lab, I have been learning more about the kingdom of Nubia as well as examining the remains I have been cleaning and labeling. Below will be photos of bones I have been cleaning so I will give another warning that if you don't like seeing human skeletal remains, this may be considered graphic. The first photo is of vertebrae I have been cleaning and the other one is of a pretty intact pelvis.


Now below will be a photo of two clavicles and a mandible. The bigger clavicle is from burial 09-01( excavated in 2009 in burial site 1) which seems huge in contrast to the smaller clavicle from burial 09-30( excavated in 2009 in burial site 30). This is really interesting because the pattern that Annie sees is that people from burial 09-01 seem to be larger in stature and have more muscle than people from 09-30. From the photo of the mandible, we can see signs of ante-mortem tooth loss which you can see from the filled space between two holes( where teeth previously were). Ante-mortem tooth loss is tooth loss that occurred before the person died.


Other interesting facts I learned from Annie this week are about reactive bones and the accuracy of getting data from children's skeletal remains. Bones that are indicative of pathologies are reactive so there is either bone growth where there shouldn't be or bone loss in other cases. Looking at ribs is a good indication of whether someone had any respiratory problems. Annie was telling me that from the skeletal remains, she has found that there were many respiratory problems in Nubia which includes the prevalence of Tuberculosis. As for the accuracy of children's remains, it is impossible to tell what sex a child is. Unless the skeletal remain is in their late teen years, sex remains a mystery because the major changes that indicate the differences between male and female occur at puberty. However, bioarchaeologists are working on finding an accurate model to discover whether a child's remain is male or female.

As for more about Nubian background and history, the two articles that Dr. Baker had us read for this week were "The History of Nubia" by Marjorie Fisher and "Burial Customs in Ancient Nubia" by Peter Lacovora and Christian Knoblauch. "The History of Nubia" discussed the different periods of Nubia which chronologically falls into this order: Paleolithic, Mesolithic, and Neolithic; Bronze Age Nubia; the Kerma Kingdom; the New Kingdom; the Napatan and Meroitic periods; the post-Meroitic periods; the medieval Christian Kingdom; and the Islamic Period. It was really interesting to read how burials have evolved from having no grave goods( Paleolithic period) to a lot of grave goods( based on social class) to very little grave goods( during the Christian period). Also, it seemed that Egypt had a love/hate relationship with Nubia where at times trade was prominent since Nubia had rare goods such as ivory and gold. Also, some pottery indicates that Nubian princesses were married off to Egyptian pharaohs. However, some written documents in Egyptian suggest that Nubians were viewed as dangerous enemies.

its complicated

Anyways, I hope all that history didn't bore you and you find bioarchaeology to be an interesting subject. I thank you all for reading my posts and see you next time!
alligator

22 comments:

  1. The history of the Nubian population marrying Egyptian pharaohs and also not being respected by Egyptians is very interesting! Also surprised to hear that some suffered from Tuberculosis. Can't wait so see what else the bones uncover.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for commenting Mrs. Silbaugh! I'm glad you find Nubia interesting and I can't wait to elaborate on more things I find out next week!

      Delete
  2. Congratulations on the FDF awards. As for the question, is there a specific type of bone that is more difficult to clean, like a vertebra or mandible bone, or are they all relatively easy by using the air chambers?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Caleb! You have to be careful with the mandible so you don't knock any teeth out. Some smaller shards are harder to clean and ribs are especially annoying, especially if they're broken because there are just so many of them!

      Delete
  3. Congrats on the FDF awards! It's an amazing feat. When cleaning bones, is there a way to mess up? If so, have you messed up?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Adam! Yes, the way to mess up while cleaning bones is to break them and yes, I have broken fragments of bones in the process. Sometime really thin fragments are snapped in two when you use the air compressor because they are very delicate. However, Annie told me that every archaeologist has broken some bones before. Though you do want to be very careful when handling remains, it is not a complete disaster if you break a bone( at least that's what I keep telling myself:)

      Delete
  4. Congrats on the FDF award, and the history of the graves was pretty interesting, I'm curious what differing philosophies between the two periods created the change from lots of grave goods to little. Also, the children thing was quite fascinating, what methods have been thought of to work that might potentially help spot the difference of sexes in children remains?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Megan! The main method to analyze sex is to look at the pelvis and skull. However, with children, the pelvis and skull looks about the same for both sexes so you can see the problems. The only other way would be through DNA analysis which doesn't work well with poorly preserved remains.

      Delete
  5. Congrats on the award. It's nice to see someone taking an interests in these old bones. Back in my day, these things were as dead as a mummy, it all just seemed like ancient history. All jokes aside, I love this post, and learning how bones show diseases that were big during that time.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ryan! I'm glad you're enjoying the posts.

      Delete
  6. Hi Nichole. By the end of your blog, I might become a history genius because I am learning so much. Congratulations on your Founder's Achievement Award! This week's blog was full of so many interesting facts. You mentioned "grave goods," and I was wondering what some examples of those would be?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Sophia! I'm sorry for not elaborating on what grave goods are. Grave goods are any pottery, usually clay and ceramic, and jewelry that are found in the burial. Usually the remain has jewlery on his or her wrists.

      Delete
  7. Wow, congrats on your FDF award! It's quite amazing to hear both of your passions in your blog posts and adds to the remarkable achievements that you have accomplished! For your SRP, are you aware of any factors which may have led to burial 09-01 having bones of more muscle in comparison to the 09-30? I find the derivation of these characteristics really interesting so I would love to hear more about that!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Aparna! Dr. Baker and Annie are trying to figure out why at one site the remains seem to be more muscular. Nubia is a very large region so Annie thinks that of course not all people look the same because of gene flow.

      Delete
  8. Dang, you're getting to learn a lot about the history and remains. This week you put a spot light on a couple specific remains, so I was wondering if you have a type of remain or bone that you liked the most?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Luke! Thanks for commenting. I thought cleaning the mandible was pretty cool, especially with the teeth still there. With the mandible, it doesn't feel like I'm cleaning a piece of bark.

      Delete
  9. Hey Nichole! This week you mentioned that many remains indicate tuberculosis. Because of this, I was wondering what the main cause of mortality in Nubian society was: violence, disease, malnutrition? Thanks again!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Brian! It depends on what period of Nubia you're looking at. I know one main consistency is malnutrition and parasitic diseases because of poor diet and parasites from unclean water of the Nike river.

      Delete
  10. Hi Nichole! It's so cool that you got the chance to see a discovery in progress! I was just wondering, how exactly does bone structure tell the sex of the Nubians? Also, how big is the mandible bone in comparison to your hand? It looks huge in the picture!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Urmi! To determine sec differences archaeologists look at the pelvis and skull where the pelvises of females are large than males and the skulls of males tend to be larger and broader. The mandible is actually around the same size as my hand . I think the photo just makes it look larger.

      Delete
  11. Hi Nichole! The fact that you are able to gain so much hands-on experience within you Senior Project is amazing! Question for you, is there a map of Nubia and all the burial sites that were excavated in order to acquire so many bones?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Liam! Thanks for commenting. I believe I posted a picture of the area of Nubia in my First Week post.

      Delete