I'm pleased to say that my week spent at the BONE lab has been awesome! As for how my days are going, I have been cleaning and labeling more bones for this week. All the skeletal remains from burial 5 have been cleaned and labeled so now I'm helping with cleaning and labeling skeletal remains from burial 6. As another precaution, I will be showing photos of human remains that some people may find graphic. Without further ado, below are photos of the last tray of cleaned remains of burial five and skeletal remains of burial 6!
Today, after cleaning some bones, I had the chance to look at field forms and add data to spreadsheets where I can hopefully get some statistics using R later. Reading through the forms has really been eye-opening since I got to view observations written by archaeologists in the field and the forms still had Nubian sand on them! The burial site I've been inputting the data for is from the Kerma period. Just as a side note, in contrast to Kerma period burials which involved tumuli of scattered rocks and a shaft, Christian period burials involved chambers where bodies were buried in an extended position with the head facing west and feet facing east. From looking at the field records, it looks as if almost every burial shows signs of looting. Looting often means that skeletons are in bad condition and some bones are probably missing.
On a brighter note, every Wednesday, all of Dr. Baker's interns have discussions with her on articles she sent us. For today's discussion, we interns read Dr. Baker's "The Fourth Cataract and Beyond" as well as "Biocultural Investigations of Ancient Nubia". We discussed the political changes between the Kerma and Christian period which involved the moving of the capital in Napatan to Meroe. In the late Meroitic period, there is an increase in interpersonal violence as archaeologists find evidence of increased trauma in the remains from this period. Dr. Baker thought that perhaps it was because there was an increase of nomadic incursions from the north. As a result, more fortresses were built, like the one the skeleton in the green trunk was from!
Another interesting discussion we had was on the nicknames that archaeologists give skeletal remains. Dr. Baker and Annie affectionately call a male skeletal remain that was pierced through his sternum by an arrow "Pierce". Also, Dr. Baker and Annie call a female skeletal remain that shows signs of healed trauma which includes multiple stabbings, concussion, and a badly healed hip fracture "Car Crash Lady". It was interesting to hear how some archaeologists find giving skeletons these nicknames very disrespectful. However, Dr. Baker brought up the point that by giving these remains nicknames, we are giving them a character that we can relate to as people rather than as 03-01 Burial 5.
I hope you guys like my Week 2 post! Thank you for joining me on this journey to learn more about Nubia!
What would the significance of the directions that the bodies are facing be? I would guess that the Christian East and West has to do with the sun, but, not being an expert on Nubian culture (unfortunately), I can't think of the significance of North.
ReplyDeleteHi Caleb! The Christian burials do have to do with the sun rising in the East and setting in the West. I know that the Nile flows north so that may be a possible answer for traditional Nubian burials.
DeleteHi Nichole,
ReplyDeleteI was wondering if you know any more about why most of the bodies were buried and positioned north. What part of the weather and climate might have made them want to face that direction? The only theory I might have is that it was out of respect/appreciation for the rain and the ability to grow crops. Do you think it could be related to that?
Also, the nicknaming controversy is quite interesting. I can see why some might find it both respectful and disrespectful.
Keep taking awesome pictures! Looking forward to learning more about the burial sites.
Hi Ms. Silbaugh! Thank you for commenting. I know that the Nile River flows north which may be a possible answer for why traditional Nubian burials have bodies facing Northward.
DeleteHey Nicole! It seems like you've been enjoying your project more and more as the weeks go by. Do you agree with giving remains nicknames or do you swear against it? Hope you have fun in San Diego!
ReplyDeleteHi Adam! I just want to let you know that I do spell my name with an h so it's "Nichole". I am really enjoying my project as the weeks go by! I definitely understand how some archaeologists take offense to giving remains nicknames as the remains real names would have been something entirely different. However, I do think that giving remains nicknames gives a character so they are remembered even thousands of years after they were buried.
DeleteHi Nichole! It must be so much fun interning there! What do you enjoy more, the discussions or the actual labeling and cleaning? Also, how did the dance competition go in San Diego? :)
ReplyDeleteHi Urmi! I really enjoy our article discussions. Cleaning and labeling bones is good for processing information that you read from the articles. The dance competition went well! My dance group got a Founder's Award so it was pretty nice! Dance groups come from all over the country, even from Hawaii!
DeleteHey Nichole! This post gave incredible insight into your lab experience and sounds so fun! I don't have any pressing questions as of now but I'm sure to have many in the future to learn more about your amazing project!
ReplyDeleteHi Aparna! Thanks for commenting and I'm glad you're enjoying my posts.
DeleteHey Nichole! I appreciate you giving some extra background information on periods in Nubia and the differences between them. Regarding the missing bones in the burials, did that result from nomadic incursions or just deterioration over time, so some bones were missing?
ReplyDeleteHi Brian! The missing bones in the burials resulted from the looting that occurred where robbers steal the grave goods and do not care where they toss the remains or whether the remains stay intact.
DeleteHi Nichole. There were so many interesting facts in this week's blog. I especially loved the nicknames for the bones. What has been the most interesting bone you have labeled so far? Have fun with the Greek Folk Dance Competiton. I hope you give us an update of how it went.
ReplyDeleteHi Sophia! One of the most interesting bones was a mandible that showed signs of ante-mortem tooth loss which basically means that the person lost a tooth when they were alive.
DeleteHi Nicole,
ReplyDeleteThis was really interesting, I didn't know that the body positions of skeletal remains could give away the period they were buried in. The trauma history and nicknames were fascinating, but what kind of archeologists/scientists are offended by the nicknames?
Hi Megna! I just want to let you know I spell my name with an h so it's "Nichole"( I know it's not usually spelled like this). I think the divide between archaeologists over nicknames is just based on personal views on how remains should be treated.
DeleteWow, that is really cool how the interns have those discussions and how you get to hear how archaeologists do their jobs. Are there any things that you think would be interesting to discuss on those Wednesdays?
ReplyDeleteHi Luke! I think a topic I would like to discuss on Wednesdays is Nubian religion in comparison to Egyptian religion since Dr. Baker mentioned that Egyptians borrowed some of their gods from Nubians.
DeleteHi Nichole! I am sorry I'm commenting late, I thought I commented on your blog yesterday but I guess something was wrong. It's awesome to see you progress in your Senior Project, as what you are doing is extremely interesting. Question for you, when originally planning your Senior Project, did you want to study something as remote as Nubia?
ReplyDeleteHi Liam! When I originally planned the Senior Project, I was thinking I was going to do something medical related like so many people are doing at Mayo Clinic or even something psychologically related at a clinic. However, when I started looking at the Global Health program at ASU and the research projects offered at the School of Human Evolution and Social Change, I saw some really interesting projects like the one I'm involved in. Dr. Baker teaches Global History of Health. Also, I think that Nubia definitely isn't remote; it just hasn't been as examined by archaeologists who are preoccupied with Egypt. After reading more about Nubia and Egypt's relationship, Nubia seemed to definitely be a very influential empire.
DeleteHi Nicole, I am austonded by your research. Can you explain how your findings of wounds and concussions relate to the history of Nubia?
ReplyDeleteHi Ethan! I just want to let you know I spell my name with an h so it's "Nichole"( I know it's not usually spelled like this). Examining skeletal remains reveals the life pathways of individuals and how past Nubian society functioned. So if at a certain time period there are signs of more violence, archaeologists are the ones to question why and try to find more evidence to make more hypotheses to what may have been the cause of the violence.
DeleteWow. I must say I am a bit jealous of all the fun you are getting to have in the lab! I am curious, how many more bones are left to clean? Once you run out of bones, will the lab travel to collect more?
ReplyDeleteHi Ms. Conner! We have a lot more burials left to clean which should last more than this semester so we won't be running out of bones anytime soon!
DeleteHi Nicole. I am impressed b the progress that you have made during your project. I love how you use your research to combine the fields of history and biology, through your use of autopsy data from the skeletons. Could you elaborate on the political changes that occurred between the Kerma and Christian period. And could you also elaborate on why some archaeologists believe it is disrespectful to give nicknames to these skeletons.
ReplyDeleteHi Ethan! From the Kerma to Christian period there was a shift in power from Nubian control to Egyptian control and we can see from burials a more Egyptianized influence in the later period. Archaeologists just have their own opinions about how remains should be treated and respected which is the reason for the nick naming controversy.
Delete